Kremlin critic Alexei Navalny, comatose in a Berlin with suspected poisoning, was under covert surveillance, Russian media reports
Igor Volkov AP
MOSCOW — As Russia’s most prominent opposition politician was fighting for this life in a Berlin hospital Sunday, Russian media reported that he was under constant surveillance by federal security agents during the Siberian trip where he fell ill with suspected poisoning.
Alexei Navalny was evacuated from the Siberian city of Omsk to Berlin Saturday in a medical ambulance funded by the foundation of Russian philanthropist and former telecommunications mogul, Dmitry Zimin, after doctors initially denied permission for him to leave the country.
The plane departed for Germany in the early hours of Saturday morning and a convoy of ambulances heavily guarded by German police delivered him to Berlin’s Charité hospital at 8.47 a.m.
Navalny was comatose and in a critical condition when he was admitted to the hospital Saturday. The hospital said late Saturday that no new information on Navalny’s health would be available before Monday.
Navalny’s emergency evacuation to Berlin followed days of wrangling as Alexander Murakhovsky, chief physician at Omsk Emergency Hospital No. 1, denied permission for Navalny to be transferred to German care. Navalny’s colleagues and supporters accused authorities of endangering his life and trying to cover up a proper investigation of the suspected poisoning.
Navalny collapsed on an early morning flight from Tomsk to Moscow early Thursday after visiting Novosibirsk and Tomsk. The flight was diverted to Omsk. According to Navalny’s associates, Omsk doctors initially seemed willing to cooperate about his evacuation, but then plain clothes officials and security agents swarmed the hospital and doctors denied permission for him to leave.
Only after intense international scrutiny and expressions of concern from German Chancellor Angela Merkel and French President Emmanuel Macron was Navalny finally granted permission. Supporters fear that the delay may have compromised his chances of survival.
A Russian news report cited sources in Russian security agencies who said Navalny was subject to an intense plainclothes surveillance operation during his entire trip.
The report in Moskovsky Komsomolets published details of the surveillance of his every movement, including what he and his associates ate, who he met, his credit card records, shopping receipts, where he stayed, what vehicles he traveled in, even down to a sushi order and a nighttime swim in the river.
Navalny was extremely cautious when he traveled, keeping a low profile and taking safety precautions, according to the security agents cited in the report. He stayed in safe houses in the Siberian city of Novosibirsk and in a hotel in Tomsk. In the hotel, Navalny’s team took more rooms than they required and Navalny did not stay in the room that was registered in his name, according to the report.
Navalny’s spokeswoman, Kira Yarmysh, called the report “amazing stuff,” adding that Navalny knew he was under constant surveillance.
“The scale of the surveillance does not surprise me at all,” she tweeted Sunday. “We were well aware of it before. But it’s amazing that they did not hesitate to tell everyone about it,” she wrote, commenting on the report.
Another Navalny aide Leonid Volkov wrote on Facebook that the report indicated the intense level of routine surveillance that Navalny faced when traveling to the regions: “A huge number of employees in civilian clothes are involved, routes are tracked, all movements, hotels, meetings. Excuse me, but actually why? Is Navalny a wanted criminal?”
When Navalny left Novosibirsk in two vehicles, agents set up a tracking operation.
“The entire tour of the oppositionist was well-concealed and even the ‘federals’ did not know about his plans,” the report said, referring to federal security agents. “Therefore, covert surveillance was established for the cars. In the highway there was a fork in the road to Kemerovo and Tomsk. The convoy was accompanied by law enforcement officers disguised as civilians from both cities.”
The Omsk region Ministry of Health Saturday announced that no signs of known toxins had been found in Navalny’s system, only traces of alcohol and caffeine. Anastasia Vasilyeva, head of the Alliance of Doctors, an independent group of doctors aligned with Navalny, said he never drinks alcohol.
Yarmysh said on Saturday that Navalny’s stable condition throughout the flight only confirmed that nothing had ever prevented Navalny from being evacuated when he urgently needed it.
Policy editor of independent newspaper Kirill Martynov wrote in a commentary that there was no explanation for Navalny’s sudden coma other than poisoning, which appeared designed to kill him or disable him and remove him as an effective opponent. But he doubted Russian law enforcement would ever find the culprits.
“We learned the hard way that cases of assassinations and murders of public figures in Russia, critical journalists and opposition politicians are not investigated.
“For a full two days, all the power of the Russian state was thrown into hiding the traces of what happened at the Tomsk airport,” he wrote, adding that, “Omsk doctors took up combat duty — under the close tutelage of the competent authorities — and for two days gave out more and more contradictory and absurd versions of what had happened, ranging from poisoning with a substance that is found in plastic cups, to a sharp spontaneous drop in blood sugar levels.”
Navalny is one of Russia’s sharpest Kremlin critics, known for his scathing YouTube exposes of corruption and graft by Russian politicians, bureaucrats and oligarchs.
He was barred from running in a presidential election in 2018 and has been frequently jailed for organizing unsanctioned protests. In July, he was forced to shut down his Anti-Corruption Foundation after it was crippled by fines. He pledged to immediately start up a new organization that would do the same work.
In March, authorities froze his bank account and those of all his family members including his parents, daughter and even his 11-year-old son Zakhar.
He is the latest in a succession of Kremlin critics who suffered suspected or confirmed poisoning. These include crusading journalist and Kremlin critic Anna Politkovskaya who fell ill on a flight in 2004 after drinking tea. She survived but was shot dead outside her apartment in 2006.
Another vocal critic of President Vladimir Putin living in exile in London, Alexander Litvinenko, a former intelligence agent, was poisoned with Polonium-210 while drinking tea in a London hotel. Litvinenko often criticized corruption in Russia under Putin. A British inquiry later found that Putin probably approved his murder.
In 2018, Sergei Skripal and his daughter Yulia nearly died when Russian agents poisoned them with the deadly Soviet-era nerve agent Novichok (or The Newcomer.)
Pussy Riot member Pyotr Verzilov, who ran onto the pitch dressed as police with other members of the group at the World Cup soccer final in front of Putin and world leaders in 2018, fell ill with suspected poisoning just weeks later.
Like Navalny he was evacuated to Berlin’s Charité hospital for treatment. Doctors there said it was “highly plausible” that he had been poisoned.
Other Kremlin opponents, including prominent opposition leader Boris Nemstov, have been assassinated. Nemtsov was shot dead on a Moscow bridge near the Kremlin in 2015, walking home after eating out.
Russian opposition leader Alexei Navalny, in coma and ‘critical,’ taken to Berlin after suspected poisoning
Russian opposition leader Navalny is hospitalized after suspected poisoning, spokeswoman says
How Navalny combined protests and anti-corruption campaigns to take on the Kremlin
Let’s block ads! (Why?)
, World reports