Why the bond market might not suffer another taper tantrum when the Fed signals its ready to move
A test looms for financial markets as more Federal Reserve officials signal theyre ready to start thinking about the day theyll need scaling back their program of $120 billion a month in bond purchases.
The question is whether that can occur without sparking a repeat of the 2013-14 taper tantrum. Bond traders have tortured memories of the Treasury market selloff that sent yields soaring after then-Fed Chairman Ben Bernanke told lawmakers the central bank could begin to pare back the bond purchases implemented in the 2007-09 recession if the economy continued to improve.
Some analysts see fears of repeat of that tantrum as likely unwarranted.
Steve Barrow, head of G-10 strategy at Standard Bank, says investors are unlikely to fret much when the Fed begins to discuss taper plans. But jitters are understandable, he said, in a note.
After all, investors who are convinced the only thing holding up asset prices, particularly bonds, is the Feds buying will note that the central banks assets have doubled to around 36% of gross domestic product since the start of 2013, Barrow said. And the liquidity crunch that accompanied the March rise in Treasury yields is likely stoking concerns that if a taper prompts Treasury holders to head for the exit, the door might be a very small one indeed.
But Barrow argued that those worries are outweighed by reasons why the market should take a taper in stride. After all, he wrote, there have been other instances of the Fed tightening monetary policy since 2013 that didnt result in a freak out.
Those include a number of rate increases from December 2015 through the end of 2018, with the Fed going beyond tapering in 2018 to actually shrinking its balance sheet by letting maturing bonds roll off.
Neither of those events caused much pain for the Treasury market, perhaps thanks to liquidity in the system, he said. In the 2016-18 period, banks were parking up to $450 billion in cash a day at the Fed through its reverse repo facility, compared with around $100 billion in 2013.
Now, reverse-repo facility usage is soaring again, topping $480 billion on Thursday.
If liquidity stays at this sort of level, or rises further, we may find that the market copes far better with a taper announcement than it did in 2013, Barrow said.
Read: Fed reverse repo facility sees record $485.3 billion of overnight demand from Wall Street awash in cash
The strategist also noted that the Fed, unlike in 2013, wont be leading the way when it comes to tapering. The Bank of Canada has already started to do so, and some central banks appear likely to lift interest rates before the Fed tapers. That may take some of the sting out of the Fed move.
And if the others tighten because they fear an inflation threat, tapering by the Fed could be a positive for bonds and global risk appetite by showing it isnt falling behind the curve, he argued.
That doesnt mean it will be all smooth sailing ahead.
Standard Bank still looks for the 10-year yield
to rise above 2% by the end of the year, but as a result of rising growth and a pickup in inflation rather than a reaction to the Fed talking about tapering, he said.